We have had quite a few emails over the last month inquiring about our 2015 garden experiments.  Many wanted to know how the red plastic mulch in the tomato rows worked out – while others were curious about the method of growing all of our potatoes in crates.

So we thought for today’s Sunday Farm Update – we would take a little time to go over the results and share some of the winners – and losers of the 2015 garden experiments.

We have a lot of fun trying out new things each year in the garden, and just like in life – some work out perfectly – while others you simply chalk up to a lesson well-learned!  But as the old saying goes, when you stop trying – you stop learning – and where is the fun in that?!

So with that said – here is a look at our 2015 experiments:

What Worked:

The Potato Crates

After successfully experimenting last year with growing some of our potato crop in home-made wooden crates – we went “all-in” this year, planting our entire crop with the crate method.

The crates growing in Mid June
The crates growing in Mid June

We planted them in a loose mixture of straw, compost and dirt – filling up the crate with more soil mix as the potatoes continued to grow.  I was a little nervous planting our whole crop with the method – but it worked out beautifully!  Yields came in at about a bushel-full of potatoes (about 25 lbs.) for every small crate we planted. Not bad for just a few pounds of cut potatoes planted in each, and very little work in planting, maintaining and harvesting the entire crop!

One additional note on the experiment – we used two sizes of home-made crates for planting : smaller crates measuring  36″ long x 24″wide x 18″, and a few large ones that were 8′ long x 24″ wide x 18″ high.  Although the longer crates worked just as well in growing the crop – they WERE NOT as easy to flip and harvest with all of the weight by the end of the season!  For next years crop – we will simply use a series of the small crates to plant our potatoes in.

See: Growing Potatoes Vertically – How We Made Our Potato Crates

Simple Raised Beds For Small Crops:

Over the past few years, we found it a little harder to grow and maintain our smaller crops like lettuce and kale in our long raised rows.  With the small seeds, thinning and weeding process – sometimes the open edges made it difficult to keep the rows maintained.

Growing our small crops in raised beds has been a huge success!
Growing our small crops in raised beds has been a huge success!

This year, we constructed 6″ high, 8′ long x 18″ wooden raised beds in a few rows of the garden for the sole purpose of growing those smaller seed crops.

We still love our raised rows for the remainder of our crops, but the simple edged beds made from inexpensive untreated pine lumber made planting and maintaining small crops a breeze. We added a total of 8 raised beds – and all of them were filled multiple times throughout the year with ready to harvest crops of lettuce, arugula, kale, onions, carrots and radishes. Without a doubt – the raised beds were a Big Winner!  See : Creating Simple Raised Beds For Small Crops

Natural Bark Mulch For Walking Rows:

We have always used straw and leaves in our walking rows to control weeds – but this year we decided to switch to a heavy coat of fresh bark mulch in the pathways.

The bark mulch in the walking rows kept weeding to a minimum
The bark mulch in the walking rows kept weeding to a minimum

The straw / leaf combo had always worked well – but had to be re-applied often throughout the year – and when we ran out of leaves – the straw could start to get costly.

We found a local sawmill that had a supply of freshly shredded bark as an inexpensive by-product of their lumber operations. It was 100% natural with no additives or treatments – and it worked perfectly for creating permanent walking rows to keep out the weeds.  In fact – we spent no time at all weeding in our walking rows this year – and it looks like it will easily hold up for another year or two without having to reapply at all.

What Didn’t Work:

Red Plastic For Tomatoes

Over the last few years, we had continued to read about the benefits of red plastic for tomatoes and it’s promise of a higher yielding tomato crop. This past year, we planted a few of our rows with the red plastic to see if it really works.

Tomato red
The red plastic tomato growing experiment was certainly not a winner in our garden this year

For us, it was simply a huge disappointment! Not only was it hard to install (taking nearly 45 minutes to plant a row – a process that usually takes about 5 minutes), but it also required the use of metal pins every 12″ or so, making it very difficult to remove later.  As for the yields, they were actually way less than in our traditionally grown rows – with no early ripening detected at all. Last but not least – they simply looked ugly in our rows! 🙂

Our verdict – there is no need to hassle with it!

Growing Popcorn Out Of The Garden:

Like the growing of our tomatoes without red plastic – sometimes, it’s simply better to stick with what works well!  We decided this year to plant our popcorn in a newly landscaped bed area at the top of the entrance – hoping that the ornamental look and feel of the corn stalks would add a little texture to the bed space.

This year's popcorn harvest will not be enough to carry us through our winter snacking!
This year’s popcorn harvest will not be enough to carry us through our winter snacking!

The top of the hill area proved to be too windy and unprotected – and the popcorn crop was damaged by an early season windstorm.

The resulting crop was about 15% of our normal yield – and needless to say, next year, the popcorn will find a home back in the friendly confines of the raised rows in our main garden!

In the meantime, it looks like we will be purchasing some organic popcorn to get us through our nightly winter snacks at the farm!

Happy Gardening! – Jim and Mary

If you would like to receive our Sunday Updates each week – be sure to sign up to follow the blog via email in the right hand column, “like” us on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter.



Tagged on:                                     

16 thoughts on “The 2015 Garden Experiments – What Worked, And What Didn’t!

  • October 31, 2015 at 10:15 pm

    Enjoy ur tips. Getting into to gardening. Thank you

    • November 1, 2015 at 3:15 pm

      So glad to hear Tammy and hope you enjoy gardening as much as we do!

  • October 29, 2015 at 9:08 am

    Your garden looks beautiful! I have a question about how you grow your tomatoes. I notice you have them staked to nice post. How often do you rotate the tomato growing area? It looks like a lot of work to put in all of those post then to have to rotate crops. Thank you!

  • October 26, 2015 at 11:55 am

    Great write up. Thank you for sharing it with us.

  • October 26, 2015 at 9:50 am

    I’m curious how you store your potatoes over the winter months??

  • October 25, 2015 at 10:24 pm

    I’ve been wondering about that red mulch–seems like you confirmed my suspicions: gimmick. I’m going to build me some crates over the winter for potatoes, though. Looks like a great idea.

  • October 25, 2015 at 6:50 pm

    I have put in 16 crates with old coral fencing and planted 16 different variety of potatoes. We can lift pieces off the sides and add some as they grow. We are in Australia so just in our spring with so little rain and heading into the dry part of the el nino so I have used some straw and lots of compost to keep filling them up…will let you know how I go. Peter Cundall from the ABC Garden show here uses squaresof white plastic around each plant ( thick pieces cut to go around ) as he is in Tasmania where it is rather cold to keep the bottoms of the tomaotes warm in the soil and when the weather warms up he slides them out from under the tomatoes. Thanks for letting me know the red is not such a good idea. Watch for those little slaters. I have millions at the moment as we are so dry and they have been wiping out the bean and tomatoe seeds as they sprout out of the ground. We also have wicking beds here with are fabulous with so little watering to do as water is an issue when you use only tank water. With worms in the wicking beds we put plastic pipe with holes in like periscopes with holes in the bottom end on the sides. They have a lid on them we screw down and just pop all the food compost in them under ground and move them over every once in awhile to another spot in the bed. We do not have to turn the food compost ( we are in our mid 60’s ) and the worms are fed and the vegies are fantastic……not the best for corn as I saw one done at a community garden wicking bed like that and the corn was massive but only one small cob on each as it did not have to reproduce. Thanks for sharing the pro’s and con’s of gardening experiments.

  • October 25, 2015 at 3:53 pm

    Thank you for your garden update experiments. Its always a risk to try something new… great when its a win, sad when its a fail, as so much labor and time gets lost. I love the raised beds, I have been after my hubby to do this for our kale, Swiss chard, lettuces, we do 20 to 40 ft. rows now, one large box for each perhaps. Would be less back breaking at harvesting. :). I love the layout of your garden. Good to know about the red plastic, we read of its high yields as well. We were just talking about laying a bark path, good to hear the love you have for it. Will pass this on. Good info on the potato crate experiment. I have only read of garbage can methods. Have tried neither. Potatoes are a challenge in our garden. Wonder how that would work for growing sweet potatoes?

  • October 25, 2015 at 12:55 pm

    we have been using the sawdust created by our winter wood stock for the walkways in the garden … we add it to the wood chips from the “logging” clean up … makes for really nice pathways. one word of caution when doing this … if you live in a fairly wet area – you will get a variety of mushrooms~we do not know if any are edible or not, have not gotten that far in researching that.

  • October 25, 2015 at 11:57 am

    Thanks for the up date. I followed you this year with the potato crate experiment but it didn’t work for me. In one of them the hay started to compost and the heat killed the plants (entirely my mistake) in the other crate the yield was just very small. I was wondering what kind of potato you grow? Maybe some species are better for crates growing than others?
    thanks again for all you do.

  • October 25, 2015 at 9:19 am

    Thanks for all your info. Although we live in a small home and cannot garden like we used to, we enjoy reading all the update and recipes. Any tips on container gardens? Haven’t had much luck.

  • October 25, 2015 at 9:16 am

    Appreciate reading the outcome on the potato bins. Will definitely try it out

  • October 25, 2015 at 8:56 am

    Interesting and good to know. I think you will find the bark will break down into a lovely hummus that can be shoveled into the beds. Keep up the good work.

  • October 25, 2015 at 8:55 am

    Sorry my tablet messed up supposed to say the red not there’d.

  • October 25, 2015 at 8:54 am

    Good to know about there’d plastic. Looks like most of your experiments turned out well! Great job!

  • October 25, 2015 at 8:31 am

    Always useful information. I’ve wondered about that red plastic for tomatoes. Thanks for saving me some $! 🙂 Your tips are always so helpful. Enjoyed them all. Keep’em coming!

Comments are closed.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join Our Mailing List To Get Our Free Gardening Tips, Recipes and DIY Tips Delivered Straight To Your Inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

%d bloggers like this: