Sweet Heat for Your Meat. That’s the name we jokingly came up with when we finally found the perfect blend of ingredients to create our sweet and spicy home-made hot ketchup. It’s surprisingly easy to make – and you simply cannot compare it to anything you can buy off the shelf in a store. When it first hits your mouth – you can taste the pure sweetness from the tomatoes, red pepper and brown sugar. Then, slowly, the taste turns to a slow, low burning heat from the habanero and jalapeno peppers. It’s a great condiment for hamburgers and hotdogs – or as a marinade for chicken. You can even use it as a dipping sauce for potato chips, french fries or chicken nuggets. My personal favorite though – is to substitute it in place of traditional ketchup for an incredibly flavorful meatloaf! Once made, the ketchup will store in the fridge for months. During our summer gardening season – we make larger batches and can it for use year round.
Old World Garden’s “Sweet Heat for Your Meat” Spicy Ketchup Recipe
The Ingredients :
7 medium tomatoes (Roma variety is the best)
2 jalapeno’s with seeds
1 habanero with seeds
1 red bell pepper
2 medium Vidalia onions
1/8 cup of chopped cilantro + 1 teaspoon of finely chopped cilantro
1 tablespoon of pepper
1 ½ tablespoons of sea salt
6 garlic cloves
½ tablespoon of red pepper flakes
¾ cup of brown sugar
1 can of tomato paste
Simply chop and dice your tomatoes, garlic, onions, cilantro and the red, jalapeno and habanero peppers. Put all into a large pot, add the vinegar – and turn your burner on medium low. As the pot starts to warm, slowly mash down the ingredients. When it cooks down enough you can begin to blend it all together. We use an immersion blender – but you can use a hand masher, hand mixer or food processor. Once they are all blended together, continue to let the ingredients cook down and simmer for about another half-hour on low heat, then put through a colander to remove seeds and skins. Put remaining product back into the pot, add salt, pepper, brown sugar and tomato paste along with a tablespoon of finely chopped cilantro. Let cook down until you reach your desired consistency. Remember that once it cools it will become thicker. We simply judge the consistency by putting a spoon in the pan, and if the ketchup doesn’t run off – it’s ready to go. This is where the Roma tomato really helps, it is a great paste making tomato – and thickens the ketchup well. If your mixture still seems a little too runny for your taste – you can add a teaspoon of corn starch to thicken it up. Once it is ready – you are ready to bottle and use! The ketchup will keep in the refrigerator for at least a month or two. Or you can pressure can it for 20 minutes at 10 lbs. of pressure and have it ready for year round use!


I’ve been looking for a great ketchup recipe, I’ll have to try this when I start getting tomatoes out of the garden!
Jim & Mary you just gave me another Christmas idea! I can’t wait to try this in June and July I will be canning up tomatoes and this will be one of my recipes! Thanks for sharing!
I agree, Christmas here we come. I really need to plant more Roma’s maybe next year.
Yum! This looks awesome! I am still several months away from fresh tomatoes…but I will have to come back to this when they come in!
We always can tons of tomato products. I bet this would be great with fried potatoes…. yum
It is soooooo good with fired potatoes! Really spiced them up!
My husband would love this ~ thank you for sharing!
I’m planning on starting a family soon and my husband to be and I don’t want to raise our kids on processed crap – like storebought ketchup. This sounds right up my alley – can’t wait to try it!! (Visiting from the Barn Hop)
Very clever name for your ketchup
Thanks Julie – we liked the name as well
sorry – i just now got your comments – they were stuck in spam – sorry about that – should go through from here on out now…thanks for stopping by the blog!
Hubby and son love spicy food, I will try this recipe and I bet they love it! Thanks for sharing
This sounds so good! Thank you for linking this up to the Carnival of Home Preserving.
I have GOT to make some of this! I KNOW we will love it and oh man I bet it IS fine on meatloaf! I LOVE ketchup on my meatloaf. Although I will change the brown sugar to Stevia since I am a diabetic and am watching the sugars. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing the recipe with us.
Sounds great. I also wantto make a sweet and spicy ketchup……anyone have recipes?